Why You Should Not Swim With Whale Sharks in Oslob, Philippines

As you may know if you’ve read my other posts, I’m crazy about wildlife. So when I was planning a Southeast Asia trip and heard about whale sharks in the Philippines, you know I was all over that. A Filipina colleague told me that Oslob, Cebu was the place to see them, so I immediately started researching how to get there, where to say, etc.   Literally the day I was ready to book, I somehow came across an article about how ecologically irresponsible the Oslob whale tourism is.

Background on Whale Sharks

Whale Sharks are slow moving filter feeding fish, and the largest known of all fish species.   The largest on record is 12.6 meters (41 ft). They are considered endangered by wildlife organizations. Whale  are not a threat to humans but sometimes can be curious. They only eat plankton, which is why the water may appear murky in areas where they feed. They live in tropical seas including Australia, the Philippines, Mexico and the Maldives and may live to 70 years!

Butanding the word used for the whale shark in the Philippines. Thirty years ago, fisherman used to kill them as recently and sold the shark meat. Once it became known that tourists wanted to swim with them, the whale became a protected species and the whale tourism industry was born. Swimming with whale sharks has transformed these small fisherman villages and brought tourism dollars to the areas.

Why Is it Bad in Oslob

Disrupted Migration

The sharks typically migrate and have specific feeding spots for each season. In Oslob the fisherman began feeding the sharks to ensure that they stay in the area and give tourists a guaranteed a sighting all year round.  Disrupting migration patterns in this manner has long-term effects on breeding and lifespan. This could eventually lead to less sharks for everyone to enjoy.

Poor Nutrition

Furthermore, conditioning sharks that boats and humans equals food is incredibly irresponsible and dangerous for the shark. They may approach shark hunting boats in other places thinking they will be fed. They can also be injured while getting too close to propellor boats (which don’t operate in Oslob). The sharks become easily scarred and injured from rubbing against the boats where they are fed. ≈Also, they are not getting their proper nutrition. They migrate all around the ocean to eat different types of plankton that provide different nutrients. The fisherman who are feeding them in Oslob only want them to follow the boat for the tourists. They don’t always give them enough food, just enough so they swim near the boat. Sad, isn’t it?

Inappropriate Touching

The whale shark is a protected species in the Philippines  and harassment of the sharks is illegal However, the code of conduct is not followed by tourists and certainly not enforced.

Compliance to interaction regulations was monitored by LAMAVE (Large Marine Vertebrates Project Philippines) for over 3,000 minutes. This study recorded over 1500 touches of the whales sharks equating to around 30 touches per hour! I don’t understand why the government allows Oslob whale tourism companies to do what they do, knowing how much harm is done. It’s shameful that Oslob whale tourism is permitted to run amok. Furthermore, I am disgusted with tourists who know about this yet still go because they need their perfect whale selfie to feel validated on the internet. Yes I’m being Judgy McJudgerson again. #sorrynotsorry.

For more information on LAMAVE and their work or to volunteer or donate, read here.

You Can See Them Properly in Donsol Bay

In Donsol Bay, the sharks are not fed. They naturally migrate here during December to May, with best sightings between February to April which is also the busiest time. They only allow 30 boats out on the bay at one time. There are trips at 0800, 1100 and 1400. It’s best to go on earlier boats. Personally I think 30 boats is too many but at least only 6 people maximum per boat, which is nice. Book in advance! I saw tourists who showed up the day of the trip turned down.

The difference between Oslob and Donsol is like the difference between seeing a lion in a cage or on a safari hunting prey. 

The Interaction

During whale shark interactions, you will go out on a small boat with a guide and a spotter. The local fishermen have now learned to be guides and spotters. The spotter hang out on the top of the boat searching for the sharks.  As soon as they see a whale shark, it’s go time! You get ready with the mask, snorkel and fins, while the boat gets into the idea position, slightly upcurrent from the shark.The current takes you, along with the plankton right towards the shark. Suddenly you look down, and there it is!

Swim with Whale Sharks

The adrenaline rush I felt the first time was so intense, that it bordered on panic. I didn’t realize how fast my heart was beating or how crazy my breathing had become until after the shark had swam away. They are faster than they seem. I am a great swimmer, but became breathless after the interaction because of my hyper response. The next interaction I was much calmer and remembered how to breathe normally! LOL!

Video

How To Get There

You can get a direct fight from Manila to Legazpi or take a super long bus from Manila. From Legazpi you have to arrange transportation to Donsol Bay. It’s a two hour drive. Most companies will provide a pick up and drop off service.

Swim with whale sharks

I used Donsol EcoTours and they were very well-organized, which is kind of rare in SE Asia! I stayed at the Elysia Beach Resort and I enjoyed this place so much. It is adorable and right on the beach with a really great vibe. There are hammocks and a pool as well. The staff are all wonderful. I enjoyed the pineapple and mango margaritas quite a bit!

Swim With Whale SHarks

Other things to do in the area are Firefly Tours, in which you go on a boat at night along the river and see the fireflies in the bushes lit up like Christmas lights. It was really beautiful and relaxing. You can also see Quintinday Caves, go diving or trek Mt. Mayon. I did the trekking, but honestly didn’t enjoy it that much. At least I got some exercise. I heard the caves were very nice.

Swim With Whale Sharks

*This is not a sponsored post. All opinions are my own. Cover photo courtesy of National Geographic.

 Pin it!

Swim with Whale Sharks

About The Author

csaradar

11 COMMENTS

  1. Laura M Tenekjian | 3rd May 17

    Great video and great information on how to see the sharks responsibly!!

  2. Ashlee | 22nd Apr 17

    This was really insightful, I am hoping to got to the Philippines next year so I will bare this in mind and hopefully visit the sharks ethical (:

    • csaradar | 28th Apr 17

      It’s such a worthwhile experience and it’s nice to do the right thing!

  3. Lisa Michele Burns | 22nd Apr 17

    Thanks for sharing this! I’ve always wanted to swim with Whale Sharks and it’s good to know which locations to avoid. I had suspicions about some places so thanks for highlighting the issues 🙂

    • csaradar | 28th Apr 17

      I’m so glad I found out before booking! Some things are too good to be true.

  4. ellisveen | 22nd Apr 17

    Great Post. I am also a lover of wildlife and I think it is great you point out the negative consequences of swimming with them and pointing out an alternative that is more sustainable.

    • csaradar | 28th Apr 17

      Glad to have a fellow wildlife lover appreciate my efforts!

  5. Bri | 22nd Apr 17

    I love that you gave an alternative and more ethical way to swim with whale sharks – which has always been a dream of mine! I feel so bad for wild animals that have been hurt by humans trying to make money 🙁

    • csaradar | 28th Apr 17

      It’s so sad how widespread the unethical animal tourism industry is. I’m just trying to get the message out there!

  6. kad8585 | 21st Apr 17

    Thank you so much for this share. I love hearing about these animal rights issues so that I can support the places that treat animals well. This is a dream of mine to swim with whale sharks. So glad you got to do it!!

    • csaradar | 28th Apr 17

      I hope you get to do it. Thanks for commenting. I’m happy to see people who like me don’t want to support bad places!

Leave A Comment

Leave a Reply